896 words
4 minutes
Two-Flavor Neutrino Oscillations

A neutrino produced as an electron neutrino can later be detected as a muon neutrino. Super-Kamiokande confirmed this experimentally in 1998 (and it was part of the 2015 Nobel Prize in Physics). The whole effect follows from one fact, namely that the states the weak interaction produces, the flavor eigenstates, are not the states with a definite mass. In this post we derive the survival probability for the two-flavor case from scratch. Nothing beyond basic QM is needed, just two bases, one rotation angle and time evolution.


The two bases#

The free Hamiltonian has mass eigenstates ∣ν1⟩,∣ν2⟩|\nu_1\rangle, |\nu_2\rangle with masses m1,m2m_1, m_2. The weak interaction, on the other hand, couples to the flavor eigenstates ∣νe⟩,∣νμ⟩|\nu_e\rangle, |\nu_\mu\rangle, so the neutrino that comes out of a decay is in general not an energy eigenstate. The two bases are related by a rotation through the mixing angle θ\theta,

∣νe⟩=cos⁡θ ∣ν1⟩−sin⁡θ ∣ν2⟩|\nu_e\rangle = \cos\theta\,|\nu_1\rangle - \sin\theta\,|\nu_2\rangle∣νμ⟩=sin⁡θ ∣ν1⟩+cos⁡θ ∣ν2⟩|\nu_\mu\rangle = \sin\theta\,|\nu_1\rangle + \cos\theta\,|\nu_2\rangle

or in matrix form,

(∣νe⟩∣νμ⟩)=(cos⁡θ−sin⁡θsin⁡θcos⁡θ)(∣ν1⟩∣ν2⟩)\begin{pmatrix}|\nu_e\rangle \\ |\nu_\mu\rangle\end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix}\cos\theta & -\sin\theta \\ \sin\theta & \cos\theta\end{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix}|\nu_1\rangle \\ |\nu_2\rangle\end{pmatrix}

A neutrino state can be written in either basis,

∣Ψ⟩=c1∣ν1⟩+c2∣ν2⟩=ce∣νe⟩+cμ∣νμ⟩|\Psi\rangle = c_1|\nu_1\rangle + c_2|\nu_2\rangle = c_e|\nu_e\rangle + c_\mu|\nu_\mu\rangle

with the normalization ∣c1∣2+∣c2∣2=1|c_1|^2 + |c_2|^2 = 1 and ∣ce∣2+∣cμ∣2=1|c_e|^2 + |c_\mu|^2 = 1.


Time evolution#

The mass states ∣ν1⟩,∣ν2⟩|\nu_1\rangle, |\nu_2\rangle are energy eigenstates, so their amplitudes only pick up phases,

c1(t)=c1(0) e−iE1t/ℏ,c2(t)=c2(0) e−iE2t/ℏc_1(t) = c_1(0)\,e^{-iE_1 t/\hbar}, \qquad c_2(t) = c_2(0)\,e^{-iE_2 t/\hbar}

and the flavor amplitudes at time tt follow from the same rotation as before,

(ce(t)cμ(t))=(cos⁡θ−sin⁡θsin⁡θcos⁡θ)(c1(0) e−iE1t/ℏc2(0) e−iE2t/ℏ)\begin{pmatrix}c_e(t) \\ c_\mu(t)\end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix}\cos\theta & -\sin\theta \\ \sin\theta & \cos\theta\end{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix}c_1(0)\,e^{-iE_1 t/\hbar} \\ c_2(0)\,e^{-iE_2 t/\hbar}\end{pmatrix}

Initial condition: start as a pure νe\nu_e#

Let the neutrino start out as a pure electron neutrino, i.e. ce(0)=1c_e(0) = 1, cμ(0)=0c_\mu(0) = 0. To get the mass-basis amplitudes we invert the rotation. It is orthogonal, so the inverse is the transpose, and

c1(0)=cos⁡θ,c2(0)=−sin⁡θc_1(0) = \cos\theta, \qquad c_2(0) = -\sin\theta

(These can also be read off directly from the expression for ∣νe⟩|\nu_e\rangle above.) Putting them in,

(ce(t)cμ(t))=(cos⁡θ−sin⁡θsin⁡θcos⁡θ)(cos⁡θ  e−iE1t/ℏ−sin⁡θ  e−iE2t/ℏ)\begin{pmatrix}c_e(t) \\ c_\mu(t)\end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix}\cos\theta & -\sin\theta \\ \sin\theta & \cos\theta\end{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix}\cos\theta\; e^{-iE_1 t/\hbar} \\ -\sin\theta\; e^{-iE_2 t/\hbar}\end{pmatrix}

and multiplying out the matrix,

ce(t)=cos⁡2θ  e−iE1t/ℏ+sin⁡2θ  e−iE2t/ℏc_e(t) = \cos^2\theta\; e^{-iE_1 t/\hbar} + \sin^2\theta\; e^{-iE_2 t/\hbar}cμ(t)=sin⁡θcos⁡θ(e−iE1t/ℏ−e−iE2t/ℏ)c_\mu(t) = \sin\theta\cos\theta\left(e^{-iE_1 t/\hbar} - e^{-iE_2 t/\hbar}\right)

At t=0t = 0 the two phases are equal and cμc_\mu vanishes, as it should. For t>0t > 0 the phases drift apart, and that drift is the oscillation.


The survival probability#

The probability of still finding a νe\nu_e at time tt is P(νe→νe)=∣ce(t)∣2P(\nu_e \to \nu_e) = |c_e(t)|^2. When we square ce(t)c_e(t), the cross term is where the two phases interfere,

∣ce∣2=cos⁡4θ+sin⁡4θ+2sin⁡2θcos⁡2θcos⁡ ⁣((E2−E1)tℏ)|c_e|^2 = \cos^4\theta + \sin^4\theta + 2\sin^2\theta\cos^2\theta\cos\!\left(\frac{(E_2 - E_1)t}{\hbar}\right)

Using cos⁡4θ+sin⁡4θ=1−2sin⁡2θcos⁡2θ=1−12sin⁡2(2θ)\cos^4\theta + \sin^4\theta = 1 - 2\sin^2\theta\cos^2\theta = 1 - \frac{1}{2}\sin^2(2\theta) and 2sin⁡2θcos⁡2θ=12sin⁡2(2θ)2\sin^2\theta\cos^2\theta = \frac{1}{2}\sin^2(2\theta), together with 1−cos⁡x=2sin⁡2(x/2)1 - \cos x = 2\sin^2(x/2), this becomes

∣ce∣2=1−sin⁡2(2θ)sin⁡2 ⁣((E2−E1)t2ℏ)|c_e|^2 = 1 - \sin^2(2\theta)\sin^2\!\left(\frac{(E_2-E_1)t}{2\hbar}\right)

Relativistic energy approximation#

Neutrinos are ultra-relativistic, Ei≫mic2E_i \gg m_i c^2. We take both mass states to have the same momentum pp (the usual textbook simplification, which is not strictly right but gives the correct answer here) and expand,

Ei=p2c2+mi2c4≈pc(1+mi2c22p2)E_i = \sqrt{p^2c^2 + m_i^2c^4} \approx pc\left(1 + \frac{m_i^2 c^2}{2p^2}\right)

so that the energy difference is

E2−E1≈(m22−m12)c42E=Δm2c42EE_2 - E_1 \approx \frac{(m_2^2 - m_1^2)c^4}{2E} = \frac{\Delta m^2 c^4}{2E}

where E≈pcE \approx pc is the common energy. Finally we trade the time for the distance travelled, L=ctL = ct,

(E2−E1)t2ℏ=Δm2c4 L4Eℏc\frac{(E_2 - E_1)t}{2\hbar} = \frac{\Delta m^2 c^4\, L}{4E\hbar c}

and putting everything together,

P(νe→νe)=1−sin⁡2(2θ)sin⁡2 ⁣(Δm2c4 L4Eℏc)\boxed{P(\nu_e \to \nu_e) = 1 - \sin^2(2\theta)\sin^2\!\left(\frac{\Delta m^2 c^4\, L}{4E\hbar c}\right)}

The mixing angle sets the depth of the oscillation, and Δm2\Delta m^2 sets how fast it oscillates as a function of L/EL/E.


So neutrinos have mass#

This formula is also why oscillations were such a big deal. The argument of the sin⁡2\sin^2 contains Δm2=m22−m12\Delta m^2 = m_2^2 - m_1^2. If both neutrinos were massless, Δm2=0\Delta m^2 = 0 and the probability would be exactly 1 for all LL, i.e. no oscillation at all. Spelled out step by step,

  • oscillations need two different phases e−iE1t/ℏe^{-iE_1 t/\hbar} and e−iE2t/ℏe^{-iE_2 t/\hbar} to interfere,
  • for massless particles Ei=pcE_i = pc for all ii, so the phases are identical and never interfere,
  • so a non-trivial oscillation pattern needs m1≠m2m_1 \neq m_2, and hence at least one of the two masses is non-zero.
NOTE

Oscillations only see mass differences, not absolute masses. An oscillation experiment can tell you that Δm2≠0\Delta m^2 \neq 0, but it cannot tell you the absolute mass scale.

What about three flavors?#

In nature there are three flavors and not two, so the next question is how many of the neutrinos have to be massive. With three flavors there are three mass eigenstates ∣ν1⟩,∣ν2⟩,∣ν3⟩|\nu_1\rangle, |\nu_2\rangle, |\nu_3\rangle and three flavor eigenstates ∣νe⟩,∣νμ⟩,∣ντ⟩|\nu_e\rangle, |\nu_\mu\rangle, |\nu_\tau\rangle. Each pair of mass eigenstates gives its own oscillation frequency, set by Δmij2=mi2−mj2\Delta m^2_{ij} = m_i^2 - m_j^2, in the same way as the single Δm2\Delta m^2 in the two-flavor formula. Only two of these are independent, since Δm312=Δm322+Δm212\Delta m^2_{31} = \Delta m^2_{32} + \Delta m^2_{21}.

Experimentally, two different frequencies are seen. Solar neutrinos and the KamLAND reactor experiment measure Δm212≈7.5×10−5 eV2\Delta m^2_{21} \approx 7.5 \times 10^{-5}\,\text{eV}^2, while atmospheric and accelerator neutrinos measure ∣Δm312∣≈2.5×10−3 eV2|\Delta m^2_{31}| \approx 2.5 \times 10^{-3}\,\text{eV}^2, roughly 30 times larger. (The sign of Δm312\Delta m^2_{31} is still not known, and this is the mass-ordering question.)

That is enough to answer the question. Suppose only one mass eigenstate were massive, say m1≠0m_1 \neq 0 and m2=m3=0m_2 = m_3 = 0. Then Δm232=0\Delta m^2_{23} = 0 and Δm212=Δm312=−m12\Delta m^2_{21} = \Delta m^2_{31} = -m_1^2, so there would be only one non-zero splitting and a single oscillation frequency. Two different non-zero splittings require at least two massive eigenstates. As far as oscillations are concerned, the lightest one could still be exactly massless.

Two-Flavor Neutrino Oscillations
https://rohankulkarni.me/posts/notes/neutrino-oscillations/
Author
Rohan Kulkarni
Published at
2023-07-20
License
CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
Share Post
Comments